For Whom The Bell Tolls

 This blog task is given by Trivedi Megha Ma'am. Click here

1) Critical Analysis of the end of the novel "For Whom the Bell Tolls".

Introduction :

The final chapters of For Whom the Bell Tolls bring the story to a climactic and emotional conclusion. After fulfilling his mission to destroy the bridge, Robert Jordan and his group are pursued by enemy forces. The tension builds as the cost of their daring operation becomes clear, and the fragility of life during war is laid bare.

End of the novel :

In the end, Robert Jordan and his band succeed in blowing up the bridge that they were on a mission to destroy. But it's still far from a happy ending, or a satisfying resolution. During the operation, they lost Anselmo (very dear to Robert Jordan, and most readers) and Eladio, in addition to the five anonymous men Pablo murders. Then, as they flee, Robert Jordan himself is wounded while on horseback, losing the use of his left leg. Recognizing that if he went with the others he would be too much of a burden for them to have any hope of escaping, he stays behind. He forces the love of his life to leave him to die alone in one last confrontation with the fascists. The book leaves him lying in wait for an enemy officer on the forest floor.

Yes, the ending seems to bring us back to Hemingway's stereotypical studly male character: the guy faces the cruel truth of the situation, leaves his love, and sacrifices himself to buy his friends some time. To add to that image, in his last thoughts, Robert Jordan turns to his own male ideal – his grandfather – and tries to gather himself to face death and the paralyzing pain of his wound. Nonetheless, in a tellingly human way, he admits that he doesn't prove so good at either as he'd hoped.

Plot structure of the end of the novel :

From the perspective of plot structure, the ending is nicely orchestrated. The book's first sentence is mirrored in the last, once more describing Robert Jordan lying on the "pine needle floor" and waiting. In many respects the ending ties together other themes from the book. Take the repeated image of Robert Jordan on the forest floor itself – what's its significance? One possibility to consider is that it calls attention to Robert Jordan as an individual at once alone and in relation to the larger world – of nature, yes, but of everything more generally. He feels a certain bond to that world (and not just because, as we learn at one point, pine needles are among his favorite smells). Yet it also remains indifferent to him and the (for Robert) agonizing fact of his death; we see some of that in his last thoughts. Throughout, the book contrasts the connection to nature felt by Robert Jordan and other characters with nature's (and "humankind"'s) lack of concern about their own suffering and death.

Idea of John Donne :

This takes us back to Donne's idea of human community in the epigraph, and offers us one last opportunity to evaluate it. Robert Jordan is dying for others, and tells himself at one point "I don't mind this at all now that they are away […] Look how different it would be if they were all scattered out across that hill where the gray horse is [the gray horse is dead]" (43.384).

Condition of Robert Jordan :

Yet, when it all comes down to it, he is left alone to face his pain and his own death, and feels at times the full force of that loneliness. We get the impression that at times he is just consciously telling himself things (as in the passage we just saw) to make easier on himself what is in reality very difficult. You might also wonder whether he really believes what he tells Maria to get her to leave him – that they are one, and that he will live on so long as she does – or whether he just tells her that so she doesn't die with him.

Conclusion:

The novel ends with Robert Jordan gravely wounded and left behind by his companions. Though physically broken, his spirit remains resolute. As he prepares to face the advancing enemy alone, he reflects on his love for Maria, his comrades, and the value of his sacrifice. In his final moments, Jordan embraces his fate, choosing to fight to the end and protect others. The conclusion underscores the novel's central themes of courage, selflessness, and the enduring impact of human connections in the face of war.

Write your Views on the very brave character Pilar.

As a strong lady:

Arguably the most colorful and likable character in For Whom the Bell Tolls, Pilar embodies the earthiness, strength, and wisdom of the Spanish peasantry. A large, robust, part-gypsy woman, Pilar exercises great influence over the band of guerrilleros—in fact, we quickly become aware that Pablo leads the band in name only. The strong and stable Pilar provides the motivating force behind many of the novel’s events.

A supporter of Robert Jordan and Maria:

She pushes Robert Jordan and Maria’s romance, commands the allegiance of the guerrilla fighters, and organizes the guerrilleros’ brief alliance with El Sordo. She acts as the support structure for the camp as she unites the band of guerrilla fighters into a family, cooks for all, and sews Robert Jordan’s packs. In short, Pilar manipulates the most important characters in For Whom the Bell Tolls and sets in place many of the encounters that drive the plot.

As a Palm reader :

Pilar, though practical, often relies on intuitive, mystical, gypsy folk wisdom. Shrewd and worldly-wise, she claims a deep connection to the primitive forces of fate. She claims to be able to smell death, and she describes the smell in repulsively naturalistic detail. She reads palms and interprets sexual experiences. Despite Robert Jordan’s cynicism, Pilar’s predictions do come true. Pilar exhibits the inevitable sadness that comes with knowledge: “Neither bull force nor bull courage lasted, she knew now, and what did last? I last. . . . But for what?” In the end, the only aspect of Pilar’s personality that seems not to show wisdom is her unswerving commitment to and belief in the Republican side, which ultimately loses the war.

Conclusion :

Pilar in For Whom the Bell Tolls symbolizes strength, wisdom, and resilience. By the novel's end, she remains a steadfast leader, offering emotional support and embodying the human spirit's endurance amidst the tragedies of war.

References :

"Character Analysis of Pilar." CliffsNotes, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, www.cliffsnotes.com/literature/f/for-whom-the-bell-tolls/character-analysis/pilar. Accessed 4 Jan. 2025.

 Course Hero. For Whom the Bell Tolls Study Guide. Course Hero, [publication year], www.coursehero.com/lit/For-Whom-the-Bell-Tolls/. Accessed [4 January 2025]

 Shmoop Editorial Team. "The Ending." For Whom the Bell Tolls Study Guide, Shmoop, www.shmoop.com/study-guides/for-whom-the-bell-tolls/ending.html. Accessed [ 5 January 2025].